The combination of fiscal stimulus and a turn in the inventory cycle helped stabilize the global economy in the third quarter. Risky assets around the world, notably equities and high yield bonds, continued to respond with relief, rallying significantly. Still, sustained growth remained elusive as there were few signs of demand improvement outside of those sectors, such as autos, directly targeted by government policies. Emerging market (EM) economies, most notably China and emerging Asia, showed the most resilience, raising once again talk of the possibility that emerging economies might be able to “de-couple” from the G7. However, even within emerging markets growth was uneven, with some countries continuing to contract sharply. Fortunately, policymakers around the world continued to support their economies and markets with expansive monetary and fiscal policies. While various policy “exit strategies” were cautiously floated, most policymakers remained keenly focused on downside risks and recognized, at least implicitly, that premature tightening could have dire consequences.
Growth and Inflation
The third quarter saw stabilization in global GDP, with production bouncing and many sentiment indicators moving above the boom-bust threshold. However, final demand remained anemic, calling into question its ability to help the economy achieve the “escape velocity” necessary for a V-shaped recovery.
While U.S. GDP still contracted 0.7 percent in the second quarter, this was a significant improvement on the first quarter’s 6.4% decline. Moreover, higher frequency data indicated that the economy may have turned the corner in the third quarter; industrial production, for instance, posted gains in both July and August. Still, the staying power of these green shoots was questionable given the continued negative tone on the consumer side. Real disposable personal income continued to fall, making any revival in consumer spending highly unlikely beyond the expiration of “cash for clunkers” and other stimulus programs. And the employment looked little better: the unemployment rate hit 9.8 percent and cumulative job losses for the recession reached 7.2 million.
In the Eurozone, the European Commission survey showed improved sentiment, suggesting that a recovery might be underway. Still, hard economic data has been slow to develop: industrial production for July was disappointing, as were the September Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) readings. Data outside manufacturing have been mixed at best: while household confidence continued to improve and the pace of labor market deterioration slowed, the slide in German retail sales suggested that non-subsidized consumer demand remains soft. Similarly, the U.K. recovery looked suspect, as the surge in the PMI above the boom-bust mark in July was followed by two months back below 50. Meanwhile, the unemployment rate climbed to 7.9 percent, a level not seen since 1996, and the savings ratio rocketed by two percentage points to 5.6 percent, highlighting the economy’s downside risk.
Japan’s economy, too, looked to be improving in the quarter. Real exports and industrial production recovered strongly (albeit from a deep plunge), and consumption was supported by fiscal stimulus that will be reinforced by the newly elected government. However, sluggish machinery orders suggested lackluster business investment while falling employment and wages remained headwinds for households.
Emerging economies showed clearer signs of recovery than those in the developed world but continued to exhibit greater divergence as well: while Chinese industrial production rose at double-digit rates, Russian GDP slid an alarming -10.9 percent over the second quarter.
Government Policy
The Federal Reserve (Fed), European Central Bank (ECB), Bank of England (BOE) and Bank of Japan (BOJ) left policy rates unchanged at extreme low levels and maintained or even increased quantitative easing (QE) programs. While the Fed and others did begin floating their thoughts regarding potential exit strategies, these comments were less an indication of an imminent policy shift than an effort to keep inflation expectations anchored. Indeed, most policymakers continued to express caution regarding the fragility of the economic recovery. The ECB was the most outspoken in terms of the exit strategy discussion, but even it continued to highlight downside risks. The Fed, while terminating Treasury purchases in October 2009, extended the expiration date of the mortgage-backed securities (MBS) purchase and the Term Asset-backed Securities Loan Facility (TALF) programs from December this year to March 2010.The BOE, however, remained the most concerned about the economic outlook and added another £50 billion to its asset purchase program, bringing the total to £175 billion.
For the most part EM central banks remained on hold as well, though a notable exception was the Bank of Israel, which became the first to raise rates since the crisis. Still, even EM policymakers remained focused on downside risks.
Financial Markets
Economic stabilization and improved risk appetite continued to lift financial markets: most global equity markets rallied and credit spreads narrowed. However, questions about the sustainability of the recovery led to pockets of volatility and a bout of risk aversion towards the end of the summer.
Sovereign bonds rallied, regaining some ground after last quarter’s selloff. Ten-year U.S. Treasury yields were at 3.3 percent at the end of September, 23 bps lower on the quarter, while government bond yields in the Eurozone, U.K. and Japan declined 17, 10 and 6 bps, respectively.
Inflation-linked bonds (ILBs) performed well as real yields fell across developed markets. Breakeven inflation rates (the difference between nominal and real yields) rose, most notably in Japan where continued buybacks from Japan’s Ministry of Finance boosted prices of ILBs.
Agency MBS continued to outperform U.S. Treasuries as the Fed’s MBS Purchase Program compressed mortgage yield premiums to the narrowest levels ever seen when measured versus interest rate swaps. Non-agency mortgages also rallied as investors recognized the value in this sector relative to corporates and other asset-backed securities (ABS). Consumer ABS also enjoyed strong gains owing to robust demand for TALF-eligible assets.
Corporate bonds continued to rally in the quarter; investment grade spreads tightened 77 and 86 bps in the U.S. and Eurozone, respectively. The financial sector outperformed in both markets as asset valuations improved and continued steep yield curves helped support banks’ net interest margins. Across the quality spectrum, lower tiers, especially high yield, rallied the most upon heightened market optimism.
Spreads on EM external bonds narrowed sharply, ending the quarter 96 bps tighter. Similar to corporate credit, lower quality spreads benefitted the most. Local markets also reacted positively to improved sentiment and continued inflows into the asset class, with Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA) leading the rally, followed by Latin America and Asia.
On the currency front, the U.S. dollar underperformed almost all currencies upon improved risk appetite, ending the quarter weaker against the euro (4.3 percent) and the Japanese yen (7.4 percent). The pound sterling (-2.9 percent) was a notable underperformer as investors looked to it as a potential new funding currency. Commodity currencies such as the Australian dollar (9.5 percent) and Brazilian real (10.5 percent) outperformed as investors looked to take advantage of the improved outlook for commodity importers like China. |