Economy Continues to Stabilize; Abundant Slack Remains
Financial markets and the broader economy continued to stabilize during the third quarter after the extraordinary events of last year. The Barclays Capital U.S. Aggregate Index, a widely used index of U.S. high-grade bonds, returned 3.74 percent during the quarter. Treasury yields were less volatile than in the first half of 2009 and fell across maturities. The yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury ended the quarter at 3.31 percent, down 23 basis points from the end of the second quarter.
Policy initiatives - such as the Federal Reserve’s purchase of mortgage and Treasury securities, the government’s support for consumer finance markets and near-zero short term rates - helped revive risk appetites and were the major factors behind enhanced stability. Two key programs were extended during the third quarter.
The Fed committed to complete its $1.25 trillion program to buy mortgage-backed bonds and extended the end date of the program to March 2010 from December 2009. Massive purchases of mortgages from this program, roughly two-thirds complete by quarter-end, helped hold down mortgage rates and supported the fragile housing market. The Fed and the Treasury also announced the extension of the Term Asset-backed Securities Loan Facility, or TALF program, which provides financing to investors buying consumer asset-backed securities (ABS). Originally set to expire in December of this year, TALF was extended through March 2010 for consumer ABS.
Manufacturing and housing data showed improvement in the third quarter, suggesting that the recession was close to an end. Even so, substantial slack remained in the economy, leading the Fed to announce that it would keep the federal funds rate near zero “for an extended period.” The unemployment rate moved closer to 10 percent, making any revival in consumer spending highly unlikely. Businesses continued to draw down inventories, albeit at a slower rate than earlier in the year. Industrial capacity utilization hovered near record lows at below 70 percent, discouraging new investment. Policymakers faced with these dismal fundamentals were in no position to contemplate withdrawal of stimulus programs any time soon.
Investment Grade Credit Maintains Positive Momentum
Spreads in the investment grade credit market tightened 77 basis points, finishing the quarter at an average level of 198 basis points. High grade credit spreads maintained their positive momentum as greater risk appetite boosted investor demand relative to lower yielding U.S. Treasury securities. The Barclays Capital U.S. Credit Index has outperformed Treasuries for six consecutive months1. As spreads tightened, the investment grade credit market posted a 4.98 percent return1.
Financials led the third quarter rally, outpacing the index by 223 basis points to return 7.21%1. The ongoing impact of public policy initiatives and private market capital raising helped to bolster liquidity and improve balance sheet strength within the financial system. Since June 30, financials’ spreads have tightened 127 basis points to end the quarter at 288 basis points.
The life insurance sub-sector was the top performer over the third quarter, generating an excess return of 14.78 percent and outpacing the index by 980 basis points1. Life insurance credits outperformed all sectors on the quarter, benefitting from improved credit profiles, and enhanced asset coverage from higher valuations. During the middle of the second quarter, Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) funds were made available which supplied the sector with much needed access to capital and provided issuers with liquidity and stability after suffering from substantial declines at the height of the financial crisis. Credit investors were afforded additional support after the successful capital raising efforts in the debt and equity markets during the second quarter. Additionally, there were relatively few downside surprises from the second quarter earnings season, which provided improved confidence in the general state of financial markets.
Financials were further supported by credits in the banking sub-sector. Government aid has greatly reduced default and liquidity risk for financial institutions that received support, including in some situations, direct recapitalization of systemically vital institutions. Banks have also demonstrated the ability to call on the capital markets, de-leveraging their balance sheets in the process through new debt and equity issuance and preferred exchange offers to raise tangible common equity ratios. Along with improved market conditions, banks have benefitted from a deceleration in the deterioration of asset quality. Financial institutions that are able to access private sector capital have begun to separate themselves from weaker firms as they possess healthier balance sheets and ample liquidity without depending on government support. Better earnings performance was a continuing trend and drove spread compression during the quarter as the financial landscape showed modest improvement. As a result, credits in the banking industry advanced 6.76 percent1.
Real estate investment trust (REIT) credits returned 8.95 percent on the quarter, outpacing the index by 397 basis points. REIT credits achieved gains from strong investor demand, recapitalization efforts and active real estate portfolio management. Many investment-grade REIT issuers are well positioned to meet capital needs in the near-term through debt and equity issuances, cost cutting initiatives and the possession of large amounts of unencumbered assets. Brokerage and finance companies returned 8.42 percent and 5.20 percent, respectively, to round out the financials sector.
All other sectors also outpaced Treasuries on the quarter. Supranationals, the worst performing group, surpassed Treasuries by 107 basis points1. This performance paralleled all non-corporate credits except for sovereigns. For example, foreign local governments and foreign agencies, which often offer less compelling absolute compensation than corporate bonds, soundly outpaced Treasuries yet underperformed the credit market by 170 basis points and 309 basis points, respectively1.
Utility bonds trailed the investment grade market by 8 basis points, gaining 4.90 percent. Within utilities, natural gas pipelines returned 6.06 percent1. Defensive sectors that are asset-rich or that have stable and predictable cash flows have posted modest returns as they are low in volatility. Yet, pipeline valuations were enhanced by investor demand for credits with hard assets, modest leverage and ample liquidity. Electric utility credits also slightly lagged the market, contributing to the utility sector’s overall moderate performance.
Industrials, while posting a gain of 4.62 percent, lagged the market by 36 basis points1. Within industrials, consumer non-cyclical, energy and other utility credits were the largest drags on the sector. Non-cyclical consumer companies lagged the index as consumer confidence continued to show signs of instability. The energy sector, particularly the independent exploration & production sub-sector, underperformed in line with other low-beta sectors that generated modest returns during the third quarter.
Elsewhere, refining sector credits underperformed the index by 251 basis points, generating a return of 2.47 percent1. Pharmaceutical and wireline bonds also underperformed as demand for defensive credits declined amidst an increased market appetite for risk.
BBB-rated bonds outperformed all investment grade quality tiers with an excess return of 6.59 percent, while AA-rated and A-rated bonds gained 3.31 percent and 5.18 percent, respectively. The positive momentum of lower quality names was due to increased risk appetite among investors1.
|